802: Father's Day
Note: This American Life is produced for the ear and designed to be heard. If you are able, we strongly encourage you to listen to the audio, which includes emotion and emphasis that's not on the page. Transcripts are generated using a combination of speech recognition software and human transcribers, and may contain errors. Please check the corresponding audio before quoting in print.
Prologue: Prologue
Ira Glass
Dad, now, what we're going to do is we're going to go through this thing, and there'll be stopping and starting. Hello?
Barry Glass
Yeah, I'm here.
Ira Glass
OK, hi.
Barry Glass
Hi.
Ira Glass
There'll be stopping and starting. And basically, if you feel like saying anything you want over the course of this, it'll be better if you just jump in and say it. OK?
Barry Glass
OK.
Ira Glass
For Father's Day this year, it seemed fun to rerun this episode from the earliest days of our radio show. This is an episode that I co-hosted with my dad. And this was made so long ago that my father in this recording, he's the same age that I am right now, in 2023, as I'm saying these words to you.
Ira Glass
OK, so Dad, so you have the script.
Barry Glass
I have the script.
Ira Glass
And have you been practicing?
Barry Glass
Like crazy.
Ira Glass
Can I hear just a little sample of you reading something?
Barry Glass
Sure. From WBEZ Chicago, it's This American Life, the Father's Day edition.
Ira Glass
Dad, you are such a pro.
Barry Glass
[LAUGHING]
I haven't done this in 40 years. It brings back all kinds of memories.
Ira Glass
Now, you better explain to our radio listeners in what context you actually sat in front of a radio microphone, Dad.
Barry Glass
Well, it was around 1955 or 1956 when I graduated from Maryland. And instead of getting an honest job, I went to work in radio.
Ira Glass
So here's a tape of what you sounded like back in 1956 on the radio.
Barry Glass
Oh, please don't play that tape.
Ira Glass
This is three years before I was born. And you're just a kid in this recording. You are 23 years old.
Barry Glass
Do personal problems and worries have you down? Are you disturbed by business problems, marriage problems, or emotional problems? See Mrs. K, reader and advisor. Mrs. K, formerly of Europe, gives you a reading and answers all your questions for just $1, and you'll feel much better.
Ira Glass
How could somebody, Dad, how could somebody who's charging $1 for a reading even afford to buy a radio ad?
Barry Glass
Well, look, she's been to Europe. She got her education there. So they must have taught her something over there.
Ira Glass
[LAUGHING] So, now, at some point, you gave up your burgeoning career in radio really before it took off the ground, and that was because?
Barry Glass
It was nothing important. It was something called making a living.
Ira Glass
Right, and so now you're a certified public accountant living in Baltimore.
Barry Glass
Right.
Ira Glass
Well, let me say this. Let me give a little explanation that we try to give each show for new listeners. Each week in our program, we document stories of life in these United States, using all the tools of radio storytelling-- documentaries, monologues, found tapes, anything we can think of. And today, for Father's Day my co-host will be my own father, Barry Glass, certified public accountant.
Barry Glass
And it's a real kick to do this.
Ira Glass
I know. This is our little Father's Day adventure together.
Barry Glass
You could have bought me a tie.
Ira Glass
Dad, why don't you read the billboard?
Barry Glass
Our program today will have four acts. Act One, Sandra Tsing Loh finds out that the world sees her father very differently from the way she sees him.
Ira Glass
Act 2, "And If That Diamond Ring Don't Shine," Ian Brown talks about everyday moments that test any father.
Barry Glass
Act 3, "The Moment Dad Left."
Ira Glass
Act 4, "Reconciling With Dad."
Barry Glass
A story from playwright Beau O'Reilly.
Act One: How the World Sees Your Father
Ira Glass
So, Dad, take us into Act 1, will you, please?
Barry Glass
Act 1, "How the World Sees Your Father."
Ira Glass
So, Dad, our first story today is from Los Angeles. It's from Sandra Tsing Loh, as you said at the beginning of the show in the billboard. When she was growing up, her father was not a fun dad. He himself had been orphaned in Shanghai when he was 12. He was raised in poverty, and because of that, he was just this-- penny pincher doesn't even capture it. He was miserly.
They didn't celebrate Christmas. He never took his children to Disneyland, even though it was less than an hour away from their home. There were no real vacations. Sandra tells the story once she bought a book of Charlie Brown comics for $1 at a book fair, and her father threw it across the room, furious at how she had wasted money. He was really strict. But as Sandra found out recently, not everyone in the world sees her father the way she does.
Sandra Tsing Loh
There's a kind of news that you're never prepared for, and here, last week, was mine. A friend told me that, incredibly, a local grunge band had composed a rock anthem about my dad and was performing it to great response in Malibu area clubs.
The group in question was called Boy Hits Car, and the song, a wailing rock cri de coeur powered by Pearl Jam-like riffs, was, in fact called "Mr. Loh." The actual cover of the Boy Hits Car demo tape was a grainily xeroxed photo of a tiny, wizened 76-year-old Chinese man, grinning on a Malibu beach in tattered swim trunks, which was, indeed, my father.
I have to admit, however, that the Mr. Loh in the song was not one I was familiar with. As seen through the eyes of lifeguard/singer Craig Rondell, Mr. Loh is a mystical, dreamy figure who swims naked among the dolphins. In the duality that characterizes certain types of rock poetry-- I'm reminded of The Doors-- the natural dance Mr. Loh does on the beach brings the listener comfort while, at the same time, poses a profound spiritual challenge.
["MR. LOH" BY BOY HITS CAR]
Boy Hits Car
(SINGING) Mr. Loh's not afraid to be naked, but some men fall from grace. They're not secure with themselves. He doesn't measure people by things we consider important. Can't seem to comprehend today, so he swims away.
Sandra Tsing Loh
My first instinct was that this had to be a sick Freudian joke one of my siblings was playing on me, as in, what is the most wildly unlikely, most fraught with amazing ironies, most wacky '60s Peter Sellers film thing you can imagine could happen to our family? But no, my father was these Malibu surfers' Eggman. He was their walrus. I decided to meet them. Craig Rondell, bass player Scott Menville, and guitarist Louis Lenard were all too happy to come into a studio and explain how their song came to be.
Craig Rondell
It was one day at the beach, and there was about five of us just sitting in the sand, just talking. Mr. Loh came casually walking up, and he was standing there for just maybe three seconds without saying anything. And we were kind of like, OK. And then he said, you're all victims of modern technology.
I started thinking. I was like, wow, that's deep. And then he just started to talk to us. He would sing, throughout the conversation, he would start singing. And so that's where the song, the premise kind of came from.
["MR. LOH" BY BOY HITS CAR]
Boy Hits Car
(SINGING) Mr. Loh, will you speak to me? You're the only one I understand. Mr. Loh, will you speak to me? You're the only one who makes sense.
Sandra Tsing Loh
Do you remember when you first saw my father? Go ahead, Scott.
Scott Menville
Oh, I remember. These guys probably have earlier memories, but it was in 1978 after the big fire came. Our house burned down, and we moved to Malibu West. And I remember seeing Mr. Loh stretching naked and then taking a shower outside naked and--
Sandra Tsing Loh
At the beach?
Scott Menville
At the beach. And I thought it was kind of like funny, but like not in a bad way. I thought it was interesting. That was my first memory.
Sandra Tsing Loh
OK.
Louis Lenard
I, too, had similar memories. I mean, I've been at that beach at Malibu since I was in diapers. And five, six, seven, eight years old. I was down there, and I'd notice him doing somersaults in the sand or doing headstands against the wall, naked as well.
Sandra Tsing Loh
So what did you think--
Talking to these guys, it suddenly occurred to me who my dad really is. You know how every neighborhood has its eccentric-- the cat lady, the parrot man, the guy with the umbrella hat and recycling cart who yells? Well, in my Southern Californian hometown, Malibu West, my dad is that person. It's an unsettling thing to realize about one of your own parents.
Louis Lenard
And behind Mr. Loh's back, he was known as the Naked Handstand Man.
[LAUGHTER]
For years, I didn't even know his name. I just thought he was the Naked Handstand Man.
Craig Rondell
You're going to have to do the song.
Sandra Tsing Loh
The song? What do you mean, the song?
Craig Rondell
Scott wrote another-- I'm going to put him on the spot.
Scott Menville
Oh, no.
Sandra Tsing Loh
Wait, there's a Naked Handstand song?
Yes, of course there's a Naked Handstand Man song. Unbelievably, the "Mr. Loh" song they'd recorded was only the latest in a decade-long aesthetic exploration of my father on the part of Boy Hits Car bassist Scott Menville.
Scott Menville
OK, it was like (SINGING) I was walking down the beach one day. Dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun. I happened to turn and look his way. Dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun. This is the man that we all know. Dun, dun, dun, dun, dun. And his name is Mr. Loh. Dun, dun, dun, dun, dun. He stood right there with his head in the sand. Dun, dun, dun, dun, dun. He's the Naked Handstand Man. Dun, dun, dun, dun, dun. Mr. Loh, Mr. Loh.
[LAUGHTER]
Something like that. We were like 12.
Sandra Tsing Loh
I invited my father to join me and the band in the studio. He doesn't really see all the fuss about his nakedness.
Mr. Loh
For example, at Stanford University, which I went there, too, in the men's swimming pool, everybody was naked because that's the most hygienic, most clean thing to do, you see.
Sandra Tsing Loh
But if some young people want to see his nakedness as a symbol of something more important, well, my father is happy to be of service.
Mr. Loh
The way I discovered this tape was this. One day, maybe a couple of months ago, I hitchhiked. And a couple of young men picked me up. They say, Mr. Loh, we hear that tape about you. Oh, I say, those rascals. They did tape. They didn't tell me. And it's very nice. I feel very happy, very honored. Probably if they don't write any song about me, probably nobody will ever write about me. So this is my life chance.
Sandra Tsing Loh
Of course, that's not true because I've made my career writing about you.
Mr. Loh
Yeah, but not song, you see. You see, you are on the writing. So I appreciate that, too. But I like something different. That's very precious for me, see.
Sandra Tsing Loh
Of course, with all due respect to the members of Boy Hits Car, in my opinion, my father is the least likely candidate to become a symbol of individual freedom of spiritual introspection of the healing powers of nature. After all, this is a man who believed all three of his children should get PhDs in engineering, or else they would starve in the street. Then, again, all these things may be a matter of personal interpretation.
Sandra Tsing Loh
So you see my father's nakedness as kind of a rebellion of some sort, or?
Scott Menville
No. Not actually. I just--
Craig Rondell
Just natural.
Scott Menville
Yeah, he's just being natural.
Louis Lenard
I feel that he has the ability to go beyond the general stereotype that America holds in that regard and is free.
Mr. Loh
Contact with nature, now, that's very important. Now, in the society, you are so busy, busy, busy, busy, busy. Not much time to talk to yourself or talk to the nature.
Sandra Tsing Loh
Nature, but did you encourage-- I'm just trying to remember as kids, if you encouraged us to do that.
Mr. Loh
Oh, yes.
Sandra Tsing Loh
OK, when?
Mr. Loh
Well, we did many things. We always go along the Zuma Beach to the garbage can to collect those aluminum cans. And we'd compete with the [INAUDIBLE] family. We have to go one step ahead.
Sandra Tsing Loh
Not to put too fine a point on it, but a competition to collect cans for spare change is not the sort of communing with nature, say, Walt Whitman and Ralph Waldo Emerson extolled, which brings me to another point.
I have to say, there is something sort of poignant about sitting in a room full of young people who are hanging onto my father's every word. He's like an odd little guru, they his apostles. God knows he never got that from my sister or brother or me. At one point, for reasons too complicated to explain here, my father sang the boys in the band a Chinese folk song that he had translated into French.
Mr. Loh
[SINGING IN FRENCH]
Louis Lenard
Yeah!
[APPLAUSE]
Sandra Tsing Loh
Were you crying?
Scott Menville
I must say that the tears were coming.
Sandra Tsing Loh
Why? Why? Why?
Scott Menville
That was just beautiful. That was just an unhindered true expression of something that I just felt that was totally genuine. It just gave me the chills.
Mr. Loh
Should I sing another one?
Sandra Tsing Loh
Why not? Sing another one. If this makes my father happy, well, then, I guess I'll try to be happy for him.
["MR. LOH" BY BOY HITS CAR]
Boy Hits Car
(SINGING) Mr. Loh, he finds the water and seems to wash this place off as the dolphins jump and play. He speaks to us in the sand. Do you know the meaning of life, or are you just a simple man? And then he swims away.
Ira Glass
Dad, do you have the script for the back notes?
Barry Glass
Yeah, I have it.
Ira Glass
OK, why don't you give the back notes?
Barry Glass
Sandra Tsing Loh is a writer, performer, composer, and columnist for Buzz Magazine.
Ira Glass
This is Ira in 2023, today's show's rerun. I am jumping in to say that Sandra actually has a new comedy called Mad Women of the West that's running at the Odyssey Theater in Los Angeles right now. Her dad, Mr. Loh, died a few years ago at the age of 96. And the band did a live performance of this song at his wake.
["MR. LOH" BY BOY HITS CAR]
Boy Hits Car
(SINGING) Mr. Loh's not afraid to be naked.
Ira Glass
Hey, Dad, one of the things that you often complained to me about, about stories that you hear on Public Radio is that they're too long. How are we doing so far?
Barry Glass
How long was that story, in total?
Ira Glass
The total story is about 11 minutes.
Barry Glass
That's a pretty long piece.
Ira Glass
Too long, do you think?
Barry Glass
Yeah, I think it's too long.
Ira Glass
Did your interest flag?
Barry Glass
No, my interest didn't slow down. However, if I were listening to the show at home with other distractions around, it might lag off a little bit, I think.
Boy Hits Car
(SINGING) Mr. Loh, will you sing to me? You're the only one who makes sense.
Act Two: And If That Diamond Ring Don’t Shine
Ira Glass
Dad, it's time to open up Act 2.
Barry Glass
Act 2, "Father's Music."
Ira Glass
Now, Dad, for this act, I asked you to bring in an example of the kinds of music that you, my father, used to play around the house when I was a kid, because you had music going whenever you were home on weekends and--
Barry Glass
Absolutely.
Ira Glass
OK, so what did you bring in?
Barry Glass
Well, I brought three Frank Sinatra CDs.
Ira Glass
Right on. Can you just choose a song and let's pop that on?
Barry Glass
Sure.
Ira Glass
What have you got?
Barry Glass
Probably my favorite Frank Sinatra song, "Lady is a Tramp."
Ira Glass
Now, why is this your favorite?
Barry Glass
I don't know. I just like the rhythm, like Frank Sinatra's phrasing.
["LADY IS A TRAMP" BY FRANK SINATRA"]
Frank Sinatra
(SINGING) She gets too hungry for dinner at 8:00. She likes the theater and never comes late.
Barry Glass
I remember the 60th birthday party.
Ira Glass
Your 60th birthday party, of course.
Barry Glass
Right, where we had the Frank Sinatra impersonator.
Ira Glass
Sure.
Barry Glass
Well, this is-- he sang this there. Did a pretty good job, too.
Frank Sinatra
(SINGING) Doesn't like crap games with barons or earls. Won't go to Harlem in ermine and pearls.
Barry Glass
What do you think? Pretty good song?
Ira Glass
It's a great song. And this next story that we're going to do is about a fatherly duty that is linked to a song, but not a good song.
Barry Glass
So it's not "Lady is a Tramp" or anything like that.
Ira Glass
Oh, definitely not. This song is actually "Happy Birthday." I think you're going to like this next story, Dad. It's definitely from the dads point of view. It's about being a father. Ian Brown recorded this for us at a show that we did in front of a live audience.
Ian Brown
No one arrives fashionably late for a seven-year-old's birthday party. That offends rule one of parental life-- never waste free babysitting.
[LAUGHTER]
But all seven guests at my daughter Haley's seventh birthday party were dropped off by their parents mysteriously seven minutes early. That sort of behavior is just plain rude. It was like being swarmed by a gang from Planet Tiny. They dropped their coats in the hall and immediately scattered to the farthest corners of the house like some new, instantly contagious form of biological weapon.
And I staggered upstairs with a small mountain of coats in my arms, which is not a chore I saw myself performing back when I was young and longing to be grown up. Even when I was 11, I wanted to be married because married people, I knew, had sex every night of their lives.
[LAUGHTER]
But that's another story. I was lugging coats. Back downstairs, Trish, the mother of Katie, Haley's best friend, two best friends ago, Trish shot me a knowing look. Magician, right? How can you tell, I said. Fiber optic wands by the forks.
And that was the first hint that my wife and I might have gone slightly over the top birthday wise. That we might have stepped over the strict moral boundary that separates caring, thoughtful parents who believe in personal attention and quality time from cheese balls like us who try to buy their way into their children's hearts.
It's easy to commit that social gaffe these days. My wife and I both work. The harder we work, the guiltier we feel. The more we want Haley's birthday parties to be-- well, visible from outer space would be gratifying. We'd been planning Haley's seventh birthday, or to be slightly more accurate, my wife, Johanna, had been planning it, and I'd been doing nothing--
[LAUGHTER]
--for weeks. What there was, was a cake iced by professionals in the shape of a magician's top hat, which cost 30 bucks, eight loot bags filled with thoughtful, age appropriate, peanut-free party favors at $15 a bag, and of course, the magician himself at $150 for two hours. He called himself the Amazing Robert.
[LAUGHTER]
I don't think he meant that ironically.
[LAUGHTER]
Now, I like to do something special on Haley's birthday. Still, don't you think, I said to my wife as she frantically tried to find a magician who wasn't booked three months in advance, don't you think we might be overamping? But honey, if we don't go slightly crazy, Johanna said quite logically, some other parent will. Then what's Haley going to think? And anyway, do you have a better idea?
And I did not have a better idea. My sole contribution to the magician party had been to suggest that we include a whoopee cushion in every loot bag, or at least, it was my idea to blow them up [BLOWING] and put them in the loot bags pre-inflated. In the old days, when Haley was small, we kept her birthday simple. I learned that lesson when I lived in Los Angeles near Beverly Hills.
In Beverly Hills, parents like their children's birthday parties to have a theme and a fairly significant theme at that-- manifest destiny, say, or a NASA moon shot. In LA, I never went to a birthday party that featured anything less than pony rides. And one mother actually gave out Gucci T-shirts in the loot bags. And it was hard to compete with that.
In an act of defiance, a friend of ours, a struggling writer, staged her daughter's birthday in a park, of all places. And the kids had a good enough time. They ran around and swung on swings and played tag and generally reveled in the whole two hours when they weren't under the watchful eye of a nanny or armed response security.
The grab bags contained what grab bags are supposed to contain-- candy, rather than Rolex watches. And afterwards, the Beverly Hills parents flocked, they literally flocked around our friend. Fabulous idea, they said. Nature-- who would have thought? Can I steal a theme?
But our friend Katharine is the queen of the less is more, easy on mummy birthday party. She says children want strong experiences, not new ones, which is why last weekend, for her daughter, Mary's seventh birthday, Katharine invited six girls over to string gummy bears onto extra long bamboo satay skewers. That was the theme of the party--
[LAUGHTER]
--skewering candies on a stick. There was some risk of eye injury and the entire gimmick seemed to have Freudian undertones. The little girls kept saying, I'm going to stick this skewer up gummy's tiny butt--
[LAUGHTER]
--and giggling hysterically. But all in all, it was a winner. Only one girl barfed. The entire party cost 15 bucks-- Canadian.
[LAUGHTER]
[APPLAUSE]
It is true that Katharine had a pinata. Pinatas are excellent because they entail hitting an object violently with a stick. But those were the old pre-bacchanalian birthdays. By the time Haley turned five, the year of our most corrupt and therefore most successful birthday, we'd gone as low as a parent can go. We'd hired human Barbie.
[LAUGHTER]
For $300, human Barbie dressed up in full-sized versions of Barbie doll outfits and came to your house. Human Barbie arrived in a Dodge Grand Caravan with human Mitch, her assistant--
[LAUGHTER]
--two giant mobile racks of party dresses for the girls, a tea set in a case, and two chests of makeup. She dressed the kids, discussed the possibility of multiple careers, and fed them cake. All our friends were completely horrified.
[LAUGHTER]
I might as well have said, oh, this year, Haley's having a crack party.
[LAUGHTER]
We're having a cake made of crack, too. My Canadian friends put this crassness down to the fact that Johanna, my wife, is an American. But successful? Well, it was as if the Dalai Lama had made a stop at our house. The girls were hypnotized with awe. They spent most of the afternoon standing in a circle, brushing human Barbie's hair.
[LAUGHTER]
I had the feeling that secretly, quite a few mums wouldn't have minded giving it a try themselves. As it turned out, I needn't have worried about the Amazing Robert, the magician, either. He was a handsome guy with sideburns and a wry, if somewhat resigned, manner.
He knew what he was doing, though. He started cracking jokes with the kids right away. You must be Haley, he said to one of the boys as he walked through the door. No, Peter said. I'm a boy, and clapped his hands. Hey, the magician said. No clapping. So all the kids clapped. I said, no clapping.
By the time he started pulling eggs out of their noses, you know they were goners. And I chose that moment to run upstairs. And I find I need a moment alone at regular intervals at these kiddie birthday bashes-- also at adult parties. In fact, I could use a moment alone right about now.
[LAUGHTER]
But when I opened the door to my bedroom, what do I find lying, lying on my bed, surrounded by entire mountain ranges of miniature winter coats? Two of my adult guests holding hands. Their spouses were downstairs. I must say, they played it cool. Headache, the woman said, rubbing her temples, not that I asked. Yeah, I said. These kids' parties can be brutal.
And I tell you, I left fast. I didn't want to ask. I certainly didn't want to know. And downstairs, the Amazing Robert was making cards disappear and reappear, but Trish, Katie's mom, she kept staring at the magician. I thought she disapproved of his tricks, but then she gave a little shriek. I know, she said. I knew I knew that magician! He has just come through a terrible divorce from a birthday clown.
[LAUGHTER]
Which pretty much says it all, doesn't it? It's terrible, getting older. The disappointments and the letdowns, but no child believes that. They want to get older. And if you're seven, you can't wait to be nine. I mean, nine, that is going to be the greatest because they think life just gets better and better and better the older you get.
We grown-ups, we know better, or we think we do, or at least we need to think we do. But I didn't have much time for such maudlin thoughts and, frankly, convoluted ones because a new sound was wafting in from the living room, a sound it is, frankly, impossible to be maudlin about.
[FARTING SOUNDS]
[LAUGHTER]
[APPLAUSE]
They'd found the loot bags. Crass? Sure. Cheesy? Absolutely. Grown-up? Not at all. That's what I liked about it. Thank you.
[APPLAUSE]
Ira Glass
Ian Brown is a roving writer for the Globe and Mail in Toronto, also the author of The Boy in the Moon, A Father's Journey to Understand His Extraordinary Son, and 60, My Year of Aging Semi-Gracefully. Hey, Dad, it's time for us to give stations a chance to do their local ID breaks and local promos, so I think you have a piece of copy there in front of you.
Barry Glass
I do. Coming up, one father leaves, another one returns, in a minute, when our program continues.
Ira Glass
It's This American Life. I'm Ira Glass, our special Father's Day edition. And co co-hosting with me for this day is my own father, Barry Glass, now a certified public accountant in Baltimore, but once upon a time, back in his early 20s, a DJ.
Barry Glass
Ira, you also said you wanted a song dealing with fathers.
Ira Glass
That's right. Did you bring in a song dealing with fathers?
Barry Glass
I did.
Ira Glass
What have we got?
Barry Glass
It's by somebody that you may have never heard of because you're too young-- maybe you have-- Eddie Fisher.
Ira Glass
The only way that I know who Eddie Fisher is-- wasn't he one of Elizabeth Taylor's husbands?
Barry Glass
That's right. That's right.
Ira Glass
He was the one before the guy who she did Cleopatra with. Is that right?
Barry Glass
That's right.
Ira Glass
How very sad for Eddie Fisher. This is all [LAUGHS] I know. Here I am, a person in my mid-30s, an educated person. That is all I would know about him.
Barry Glass
Richard Burton was married to Elizabeth Taylor after Eddie Fisher.
["OH MY PAPA" BY EDDIE FISHER]
The name of a song is "Oh My Papa."
Eddie Fisher
(SINGING) Oh my papa, to me, was so wonderful. Oh my papa, to me, he was so good. No one could be--
Ira Glass
Dad, it's like Jewish mariachi music.
Barry Glass
Is that on point for Father's Day?
Ira Glass
You couldn't get more on point. Actually, one of our producers--
Barry Glass
You go around singing that about your father?
Ira Glass
I will now, Dad. I promise. At least for the day, at least for Father's Day. Do you want me to do it now?
Barry Glass
No, that's OK.
Ira Glass
No, I'm going to do it. I'm going to do it. No, no, I'm going to do it.
Barry Glass
I've heard you sing, Ira.
Ira Glass
You can't stop me. (SINGING) When he would take me on his knee and with a smile, he changed my tears to laughter. Oh my papa. Dad, this is going out to you. To me, he was so wonderful. Oh--
Barry Glass
Ira, my heart is breaking.
Eddie Fisher
(SINGING) I miss him so today.
Act Three: The Moment Dad Left
Barry Glass
We're now at Act 3, "The Moment Dad Left."
Ira Glass
In this act, we have a story from Jay Allison. Jay Allison is this radio producer that all the people who kind of work behind the scenes in Public Radio, we all know him, and he does these really unusual little stories. He lives in Woods Hole, Massachusetts, Cape Cod. And one of his neighbors is a guy named Dan Robb, and Dan Robb is a writer and a teacher and a carpenter.
And Jay and Dan had an idea for a little radio experiment. Dan's father left his family when Dan was a little kid, just, I think, three or four years old. And Dan remembered that night vividly, or he thought he did. But he never discussed this with his parents. So Dad, Jay encouraged Dan to talk to his parents about this on tape. And I'm going to play you the story they put together, OK?
Barry Glass
Yeah, I'd like to hear it.
Dan Robb
I remember clearly the morning they told me they were separating. I was three, and they leaned over my bed, which was narrow, and told me this, something like, "Don't think this changes anything, but Dad's moving out." And what I remember is telling them that it was not OK.
Then, later that day, I remember watching my father's back as he walked down the stairs outside the house. They were cement and had a black wrought iron banister running up both sides. And he was walking down the steps away from me. He had a brown tweed jacket on and brown leather shoes, and he was carrying two brown suitcases. He put them in his Jeep, back when they still said "Willis" on the side, and he drove away.
Dan's Mom
The steps were cement steps, pretty steep, about three flights, three little flights, three steps, and then a landing and three steps down. And there was something crooked about them. one of the steps sort of went off at an angle. And there was an iron railing along the way, not very pretty.
Dan Robb
Now, if I looked out the window and watched Dad packing his car and then driving away, at that time, what kind of car would it have been?
Dan's Mom
Well, he had bought a little sports car because his car was in the garage, in the shop, and he didn't want to wait till it was ready, which would have been two or three days later. And he bought a little car so that he could leave right away. And he told me he was leaving on a trip across the country because that's what he had to do in order to clear his mind and get his feet on the ground again. So he packed up, and he got in this little sports car and took off.
Dan Robb
What kind of car was it?
Dan's Dad
It was a little Triumph, a little two-door. It was a neat little car, which I sort of got special for the trip. And I just wanted to-- I just drove out West. I mean, I just wanted to get away from Pittsburgh and just sort of clear my head out, I thought. And I remember telling Allison that when I got back, I thought I would want to move out.
Dan's Mom
I had a lot of different feelings. I was angry that he'd done it. I was angry that he hadn't ever taken Dan and me-- you and me on a trip.
Dan Robb
And he was walking down the steps away from me, and he was carrying two brown suitcases. He put them in his Jeep back when they still said "Willis" on the side, and he drove away. A little while before he left that day, he knelt down in front of me and tightened my belt for me. I have a picture of that. His hands are big, bigger than mine will ever be, farmer's hands or a ballplayer's hands. And he is cinching the belt gently tighter and saying something to me.
Dan's Dad
I mean, I feel bad about all of the sort of gaps when I wasn't there. And all of that time, I mean, once it's gone, it's gone. You can never get it back. And relationships, in many ways, are built of memories. And the more memories you have, the deeper the relationship. And if you're missing several years of memories, that's hard.
Dan's Mom
Well, there's a snapshot of his doing your belt up for you when you were probably three or four. You were four when he left, weren't you?
Dan's Dad
And I don't remember exactly what the season was. It had to have been fall, I think, because I remember taking a lot of pictures of you in the subsequent weeks when we get together, go to the parks and stuff. And it was all autumn shots.
Dan Robb
And he is cinching the belt gently tighter and saying something to me. I can't make out the words in the picture, which is black and white, and shows me standing there at three years old in front of the big window that let the monochrome Pittsburgh light into the living room.
The light is stark, as if all of the coal burned to smelt the steel in that city had burned the color out of the air. And it reflects off his hair, which is smooth with Vitalis, and shows his strong jaw and the depth of his dark eyes. There was no abuse in that household, no harsh words that I could hear. Just nothing. No father anymore and my mother sobbing over the dishes in the sink.
Dan Robb
What do you think you would have done after he had packed up his car and left? What would have been your reaction that I might have observed?
Dan's Mom
Oh, you probably saw me sad and mournful, but then turning back to the house and trying to look cheerful. But I also felt abandoned, and I felt that it was the end of a marriage, the end of my hopes for marriage, the end of my hopes for a family for you and me. And he left us.
But I also felt, as he drove out of sight, well, thank goodness. What a sense of relief. I am free of all that abuse and misunderstanding and bad feeling that have been going on for so long. I thought, well, at least I can be me now and not try to be something that somebody else was making me be.
Dan's Dad
The split-up was my doing and coming out sort of a combination of my own immaturity, restlessness, dissatisfaction, inflated hopes, and expectations. And I guess I just felt that I had never had any kind of freedom. Of course, I mean, I never really found freedom afterwards. You sort of think, well, you're going to change your life, and then lo and behold, your life turns out to be about the same.
Dan Robb
I was three when they leaned over my bed, which was narrow, and told me this. Don't think this changes anything, but Dad's moving out. And what I remember is telling them that it was not OK.
Dan's Mom
I didn't want him to tell you first, and he didn't want me to tell you first. So we did it together. And I remember I knew it was a terrible blow for you.
Dan's Dad
I don't remember telling you with her.
Dan Robb
Uh-huh.
Dan's Dad
You were in bed, I remember. I mean, at least I have this picture in my mind and in that little room at the Maple Heights. And I came in, and I said, started to say something like, Dan, I'm going to be leaving, and whatever I was going to say. And you somehow knew what was coming.
Dan Robb
It was not OK.
Dan's Dad
And you said, I don't want to hear it, and sort of like put a pillow over your head, and didn't want to listen. And it was a wrenching moment. It really was.
And I mean, I've thought since then that actually, when I walked out of your bedroom that night, that that was really a major turning point in my life. And I don't know, to this day, whether it was for good or ill.
Dan Robb
When my father left my bedroom, it was a turning point for me, too. It was the moment I moved outside the myth of the American family, left it and became a part of something else, something with no affirming mythology to look forward to and my restless memories of that day to look back on.
I became a part of divorce, which is like the death of the family. And I turned down a path less well-marked, less well-lit. But I, unlike my father, no longer wonder if it was for good or for ill. It just is.
Dan Robb
OK, well, I think that's about it, huh? This will be on the radio right before Father's Day. So I'd like to wish you Happy Father's Day.
Dan's Dad
Oh, OK. Thank you.
Dan Robb
You're welcome. And maybe we can make something good out of this.
Dan's Dad
Yeah.
Dan Robb
So thank you so much.
Dan's Dad
OK.
Dan Robb
All right, I love you.
Dan's Dad
Love you, man.
Dan Robb
OK, talk to you soon.
Dan's Dad
Yeah, bye.
Dan Robb
Bye.
Ira Glass
Jay Allison and Dan Robb made that back in the '90s when we first broadcast today's show. Hey, Dad.
Barry Glass
Yes, Ira.
Ira Glass
Do the next act open, please.
Act Four: Reconciling With Dad
Barry Glass
Act 4, "Reconciling With Dad."
Ira Glass
This whole show is like reconciling with Dad, though you and I, we don't need to reconcile, but.
Barry Glass
No, we don't.
Ira Glass
We don't. But Dad, this next story is about a father and son. The father was this pretty well-known man here in Chicago named James D. O'Reilly. He was an actor here and a director from the 1960s through the 1980s. And among people who went to theater, just, he's one of these people who everybody knew.
He was artistic director of the Body Politic Theater and the Court Theater. And he wasn't the most reliable dad. And his son is a guy named Beau O'Reilly, who's a playwright and a local musician and stages a lot of theater here in town. And Beau has this story about his father, including a moment in their lives when they did reconcile, in a way.
Beau O'reilly
When I was a little kid, five or six, my father would do these big variety shows, these musical revues for college theater groups. And I would often appear with him, playing the bad kid in town or the clown screaming the lines of "This Old Man" from the top of a stepladder. And at the show's end, we would rush first to the bar, where my father knew all the girls' names, and then to the train station to catch the last train home.
And I would get very tense then and hot in my stomach, like I was going to burn up and pass out. So we would often miss the last train home and have to spend the long hours till morning waiting in the train station, my father falling quickly asleep, his huge head thrown back in the train waiting room seat. It seemed to hang at an impossible odd angle from the rest of his body like the dot at the bottom of a question mark that knows it has to be there, but hangs odd and unattached.
And the scene, my father drunk and snoring, a big question mark of a presence, would be repeated numbers of times over the next 25 years. My father passed out at the family table on Christmas morning, my father nodding off behind the wheel, my father snoring through the still Latin mass, my father's head thrown back in the last row during my high school production of The Glass Menagerie.
But when he was awake, he was not totally present either. He was this silent, brooding man home once a week for our family dinner. And I would sit up all night in that train station, listening to the muted rumblings of the next morning's diesel engines and the fluttering of pigeons in the ceiling above, my father's snoring made rusty and noisy by too much cigarettes and beer.
When I was 29, something changed between me and my father. I was 29, very drunk most days. And I came home to Chicago to work for my father, I guess. I had rarely seen him in my alcoholic adulthood, his alcoholic adulthood having taken him away from the family circle years ago. And when my father, he got me this job as a house manager and sometimes understudy at his theater on Lincoln Avenue. And he was warm and kind about it, I guess.
This kindness was unusual. It was hard for me to recognize it. I didn't know whether it was kindness really or not. Maybe he just recognized something in my swaying walk and my overly bright, loud way of speaking, a kindred alcoholic spirit. We would from then on do our drinking together late nights at the pub next door to the theater, a pub where we could sit for hours, get a burger and a beer, a pub where my father ran a tab, and I was always on the tab.
Now, the pub tables were family long, with my father always at the head and crowded with actors and confidants, all with one ear pointed at my father, hoping for a good joke from him, which usually came, or some word of praise, which came rarer, but when delivered, were always delivered with a flair and a passion.
These tables would start full, full of people and huge pints of black Guinness and brown beer, but by 1:00 or 2:00 in the morning, they would be empty, except for my father and I. Me talking loud and feverish now, lovers and women and broken hearts and politics and plays and broken hearts and lost lovers and lost women and broken hearts. And me doing most of the talking, my father nodding and grimacing, looking appropriately sad.
But his eyes looking away always, scanning the bodies of the young women who moved about in the pub's waning hours. Sometimes these women stopped by the table to speak to my father, him finding sly ways to kiss and touch and pinch them, locking their eyes with his as if his eyes were gift enough to allow him his inappropriate touching.
The pub would close with us still in it, the tables having adopted the chairs and now holding them piggyback. And my father would sign his tab with a flourish, and we would part company. Me often watching him walk slowly up Lincoln Avenue, a large man with a lordly old-fashioned head, always aware that he was like something out of Shakespeare or O'Neill. He might be swaying, but swaying with a charm and a dignity.
The further my father got up the street, the more real he felt to me. There. There. That was the father I knew, half a courtyard away under the hot lights doing Shakespeare's Lear or Brecht's Galileo. And I would stand on Lincoln Avenue crying, the crying of a 29-year-old drunken baby whose father is moving away, always moving away. And that baby knows he's better off having Dad go.
I learned a lot watching my father's theater that year, wonderful productions of Playboy of the Western World and Ronald Harwood's The Dresser, Brian Friel's Translations. My father's performances were always in the center of the plays. And I was the house manager. I was skittish in a baggy suit and non-matching vintage ties, greeting the audience at the door, selling them coffee, but mostly watching the performances night after night.
My understudy assignment was not something any of us ever expected to use, but one week, here it comes. An actor could not appear, and I was to play my father's tortured, crippled son. It was an Irish play about an Irish father and his Irish sons, and I was an Irish son, never mind that I had an Irish brogue like Ringo Starr's Liverpool.
And I'd never appeared on a professional stage. There would be one rehearsal. My father not even on stage, but seated in the audience, chain smoking, hung over, barking orders, orders that moved my body hot and frightened, clumsily around the stage, me mumbling the lines and standing in all the wrong places.
And the night of the performance, I was pacing and shaking in the hall outside of the green room where my father and the rest of the cast were making up and preparing to perform. I could hear them talking, but they couldn't see me at all. They didn't know I was there.
And one of the actors said, with a good actor's projection and precise actor's diction, "Get ready for amateur night." "What did you say?" My father said it quietly, but with force. "Get ready for amateur night." "Well, he'll be fine. You worry about yourself. Prick."
Now, this is the only time I ever heard my father defend me. And I now realize the significance of that. But at the time, I was very angry. And it was the anger that burned the fear out of me like a fog on a new hot summer Sunday. And I was fine when I hit the stage. I was understudy good enough.
And when I played to my father, his eyes a deep well into the heart of Brian Friel's Translations, I actually enjoyed myself. There were moments of real emotion between us. And on the stage, my father was really there. Like I could reach out and touch him, and he would really be there.
And when the lights came down, I stumbled offstage, tripping and falling in the dark. My father was waiting, his big, noble actor head shaggy with sweat, his arms open to receive me. We, hugging, missed the curtain call-- probable first for my father. He was not one to miss a curtain call.
A few months later, my father fired me during his production of The Dresser by Ronald Harwood. My father playing Sir, a bullying, tyrannical, Shakespearean actor Sir. My father was not one to shrink from typecasting.
And one of my assignments was to meet him in the lobby, holding a towel, which he would use to wipe the makeup and sweat from his face before returning to the stage for the curtain call. I wasn't there with the towel. I had wandered off to the pub for a pint before the show ended.
The truth be told, there were probably many nights when I wasn't there. I was off crying into the phone, running off the long distance phone bill for the theater or selling dope out of the theater concession stand to my friends. I was 29 and drunk most of the time.
And my father, he recognized me for what I was. I was becoming very much like him in my 29th year, and perhaps he was embarrassed and uncomfortable having to see himself in me every day. And he was fired soon after from his theater on Lincoln Avenue. And we continued to meet in the pub night after night for many months.
Ira Glass
Bill O'Reilly is a Chicago playwright, and he's also the co-host of the Rhinoceros Theater Festival, which today's show is a rerun. It is now in its 34th year. He'll be performing on July 1 in a tribute to Bob Dylan.
["PAPA, CAN YOU HEAR ME?" BY BARBRA STREISAND]
Credits
Ira Glass
So Dad, you're sitting there in a studio in Baltimore. I'm here in Chicago. Do you have our credits?
Barry Glass
I do have your credits.
Ira Glass
All right.
Barry Glass
Our program was produced today by Alix Spiegel and Ira Glass with Peter Clowney, Nancy Updike, and Dolores Wiber. Our contributing editors are Paul Tough, Jack Hitt, and the fabulous Margy Rochlin.
Ira Glass
Special thanks today to Bob Carlson at KCRW in Santa Monica for recording Sandra Tsing Loh, her father, and the band, Boy Hits Car, and to Dave Johnson at WJHU, the fabulous Dave Johnson for getting my dad on tape and out here.
Barry Glass
Music help today from Chicago's John Connors. The story about Dan Robb's father leaving comes from Jay Allison's series, Life Stories, which is funded by the Corporation for Public Broadcasting and the National Endowment for the Arts.
Ira Glass
That was so smooth. Additional help in today's rerun from Matt Tierney, Stowe Nelson, and Alaa Mostafa. Also worth mentioning Boy Hits Car, the band that we heard from in Act 1, has a new album coming out later this year, 2023. This American Life is delivered to public radio stations by PRX, the Public Radio Exchange. Thanks, as always, to our program's co-founder, Mr. Torey Malatia. I'm Ira Glass.
Barry Glass
And I'm Barry Glass.
Ira Glass
Back next week with more stories of This American Life. Till then, don't drive like my father.
Barry Glass
Don't drive like my son.